HomeUncategorizedWhy American Health Care Makes No Sense

Leave a Reply

Photo and Image Files
Audio and Video Files
Other File Types
12 Comment threads
9 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
8 Comment authors
polarbear4orlbucfanTorabshumphreyEyeRound Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

newest oldest most voted
Notify of

It’s an interesting way to campaign for your platform. Otherwise, this video needed to be here last fall. But maybe the campaign will get some of the progressive media to run it.



David Sirota, senior advisor and speechwriter for Sen. Bernie Sanders’s presidential campaign, gave a scathing account Monday of what he believes is driving foes of Medicare for All to embrace universal coverage for the treatment of COVID-19, dubbed “Coronavirus Care for All” by the progressive writer.

The highly contagious nature of the coronavirus is leading the affluent political class to look after their own interests, wrote Sirota. The wealthy are thus in this case backing a healthcare system in which “workers are only permitted to get the absolute minimum amount of free healthcare that may prevent them from infecting billionaires.” Sirota made the argument Monday evening in a publicly available Facebook post, in which he noted that President Donald Trump and Sanders rival former Vice President Joe Biden are supporters of such a system.

Billionaires and lobbyists, wrote Sirota, can count on “gold-plated private health insurance,” and aren’t at risk when a low-wage worker is suffering from a serious—and expensive—but non-contagious health issue such as cancer.

Private heath insurance affords no such buffer when it comes to COVID-19.

A “billionaire Manhattanite and that Washington lobbyist may have great health insurance,” wrote Sirota, but “they and their families are indeed personally jeopardized by that grocery worker being unable to afford COVID testing and treatment, because that grocery worker can spread the disease to the food supply and the larger community.”

Sirota put the motivation for the narrowly focused government-backed coverage in harsh terms:

A more simple way of saying this is: the affluent political class supports Coronavirus Care For All because they fear getting COVID from poor people, but that same affluent political class opposes Medicare for All because they cant get cancer from poor people and so they don’t care that poor folk cant afford chemo—and they certainly don’t want to pay higher taxes to fix that.

In feudal terms: the peasantry is only allowed to be given the minimal amount of free healthcare that makes sure the gentry don’t get infected—nothing more.

This anti-Medicare for All but pro-COVID-19 care for all mentality puts a spotlight on a harsh truth, wrote Sirota: “the rich and powerful will only act out of fear, never out of a sense of moral solidarity—and only in narrow ways that serve their own Interests.”


Stuff like this just makes me think of “Trading Places.” Great comedy if you aren’t familiar with it, but its central theme is that the wealthy and powerful are the lowliest and most depraved members of the human race. A credo I wish more Americans shared.




I don’t know why everybody can’t see the brutality of the system. We truly are seen as the other beasts of burden. Shot up with this and that drug sedated with this and that entertainment. Just enough so that we can keep shoveling all of our money forever to them.

They have forgotten that they are also animals, and they have become the worst kind



Would definitely be good, but it’s like a public option


It’s worth mentioning that it is World Health Day. In a report released by WHO today about nurses and midwives:

The Covid-19 pandemic underscores the urgent need to strengthen the global health workforce. A new report, The State of the World’s Nursing 2020, provides an in-depth look at the largest component of the health workforce. Findings identify important gaps in the nursing workforce and priority areas for investment in nursing education, jobs, and leadership to strengthen nursing around the world and improve health for all. Nurses account for more than half of all the world’s health workers, providing vital services throughout the health system. Historically, as well as today, nurses are at the forefront of fighting epidemics and pandemics that threaten health across the globe. Around the world they are demonstrating their compassion, bravery and courage as they respond to the COVID-19 pandemic: never before has their value been more clearly demonstrated.

‘Nurses are the backbone of any health system. Today, many nurses find themselves on the frontline in the battle against Covid-19,’ said Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, WHO Director General. ‘This report is a stark reminder of the unique role they play, and a wakeup call to ensure they get the support they need to keep the world healthy.’

The report, by the World Health Organization (WHO) in partnership with the International Council of Nurses (ICN) and Nursing Now, reveals that today, there are just under 28 million nurses worldwide. Between 2013 and 2018, nursing numbers increased by 4.7 million. But this still leaves a global shortfall of 5.9 million – with the greatest gaps found in countries in Africa, South East Asia and the WHO Eastern Mediterranean region as well as some parts of Latin America.

Revealingly, more than 80 per cent of the world’s nurses work in countries that are home to half of the world’s population. And one in every eight nurses practices in a country other than the one where they were born or trained. Ageing also threatens the nursing workforce: one out of six of the world’s nurses are expected to retire in the next 10 years.

To avert the global shortage, the report estimates that countries experiencing shortages need to increase the total number of nurse graduates by on average 8% per year, along with improved ability to be employed and retained in the health system. This would cost roughly USD 10 per capita (population) per year.

“Politicians understand the cost of educating and maintaining a professional nursing workforce, but only now are many of them recognizing their true value,” said ICN President Annette Kennedy. “Every penny invested in nursing raises the wellbeing of people and families in tangible ways that are clear for everyone to see. This report highlights the nursing contribution and confirms that investment in the nursing profession is a benefit to society, not a cost. The world needs millions more nurses, and we are calling on governments to do the right thing, invest in this wonderful profession and watch their populations benefit from the amazing work that only nurses can do.”

About 90 per cent of all nurses are female, yet few nurses are found in senior health leadership positions– the bulk of those positions are held by men. But when countries enable nurses to take a leadership role, for example by having a government chief nursing officer (or equivalent), and nursing leadership programmes, conditions for nurses improve.

“This report places much-needed data and evidence behind calls to strengthen nursing leadership, advance nursing practice, and educate the nursing workforce for the future,” said Lord Nigel Crisp, Co-Chair of Nursing Now. “The policy options reflect actions we believe all countries can take over the next ten years to ensure there are enough nurses in all countries, and that nurses use of the full extent of their education, training, and professional scope to enhance primary health care delivery and respond to health emergencies such as COVID-19. This must start with broad and intersectoral dialogue which positions the nursing evidence in the context of a country’s health system, health workforce, and health priorities.”

To equip the world with the nursing workforce it needs, WHO and its partners recommend that all countries:

  • increase funding to educate and employ more nurses;
  • strengthen capacity to collect, analyze and act on data about the health workforce;
  • monitor nurse mobility and migration and manage it responsibly and ethically;

  • educate and train nurses in the scientific, technological and sociological skills they need to drive progress in primary health care;
  • establish leadership positions including a government chief nurse and support leadership development among young nurses;
  • ensure that nurses in primary health care teams work to their full potential, for example in preventing and managing noncommunicable diseases;
  • improve working conditions including through safe staffing levels, fair salaries, and respecting rights to occupational health and safety;
  • implement gender-sensitive nursing workforce policies;
  • modernize professional nursing regulation by harmonizing education and practice standards and using systems that can recognize and process nurses’ credentials globally;
  • and
    strengthen the role of nurses in care teams by bringing different sectors (health, education, immigration, finance and labour) together with nursing stakeholders for policy dialogue and workforce planning.

The report’s message is clear: governments need to invest in a massive acceleration of nursing education, creation of nursing jobs, and leadership. Without nurses, midwives, and other health workers, countries cannot win the battle against outbreaks, or achieve universal health coverage and the Sustainable Development Goals.





T and R, LD!! Good to see your OTs again. 🙂



As much as I want MfA, Gavin Newsome is moving a little in its direction. But if I heard this right on Maddow’s show, the first stop of using governmental purchasing power in a public-private partnership with nonprofits…sounds like for now bigger steps for a public option.

My videos are crappy. If I don’t see anything on twitter in the next couple of hours, I’ll post parts of the interview, using a smartphone.


It’s humorous to see Maddow still trained to ask neoliberal questions, and Newsom glided through them.


i was just saying that. they Just can’t stomach m4a



Oh I hope this goes on TV, especially in the states that have not voted!

Skip to toolbar